Skip to main content

The Best Sugar Cookies

I'm so glad Tuesday is here and Monday is over. Why do Monday's have to be so rough??

Today I can't wait to share my favorite Sugar Cookie recipe with you. These are the soft, pillow-y  kind with butter cream frosting on top. I love them. It's so hard to choose between sugar cookie and chocolate cookie. However, I've found that if you make cookies small enough you can have 2 without feeling bad-- problem solved!

This recipe is slightly adapted from the Better Homes and Gardens "New Cookbook"... 1989 (a true gem if you own it)

Sugar Cookies:
1 Cup Butter
3/4 Cup Sugar
1 Tbs milk
1 Egg
1 tsp Vanilla
2 Cups Flour
1 tsp Baking Powder
1 tsp Cream of Tartar (my addition)
Dash Salt

Preheat over to 375. Beat butter, sugar, milk, egg, vanilla. Add Flour, baking powder, cream of tartar and salt until thoroughly combined. Cover and chill for 3 hours.
On a lightly flour surface, roll out half the dough until 1/4 inch thick. Place on ungreased cookie sheet and bake for 7-8 minutes. It's best if you barely let them get even slightly browned.
Let cool then frost!

Frosting:
1/3 Cup Butter
2-3 Cups Powdered Sugar
Milk
1 tsp Vanilla

Mix ingredients, add milk until desired consistency. 

Although these are a bit of a time consuming endeavor they are totally worth all the mixing, waiting, rolling, cooking, cooling, frosting! As soon as you sink your teeth into this sweet cookie you will be forever grateful. I think this will always be a staple Christmas cookie in our home. I can't wait to make these with my kids some day.

Don't forget to save some for Santa ;)
xo.
erica

Comments

  1. They really are the best ever!!! Thanks for posting!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Will be trying these this year - am impressed that you can limit yourself to 2 cookies, regardless of the size of cookie, lol.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

goodbye summer 2026

I headed back to BHP today after what may have been the best summer ever. If you would have asked me a week ago if I was ready to go back I would have said no, but I think God does a good job of preparing our hearts for big changes if we allow him to, and I truly felt prepared walking into school today.  My classroom has a ways to go to be ready to welcome in students to meet the teacher night on Wednesday-- but I know I'll get there.  Routine is good, and I packed my lunch last night, laid out my clothes and after work today headed to the grocery before grilling up some chicken for dinner. I needed something to remind me that I love feeding my family well, being somewhat organized and nights at home after a day away. Here are some summer lasts: Mornings on the front porch with coffee + 1 kid + a game?!?!? THE BEST Also a LOT of Rummikub lately a Friday morning of cinnamon chip scones might be the best way to start the day family bike ride on the Brown's Creek Trail 12 miles w...

Wolfpack.

We had a good day with these lifetime friends of mine. PHS class of ‘04.  Linds is so good at getting everyone together. She planned this whole day and then everyone took the day off work/ got kids out of activities and sports and made the effort to see one another.  Friendship of 35 years is a true gift. I feel like these girls watched me grow up. From playing boxcar children in the basement to jr high shenanigans/ all the trips to Treasure Island to studying abroad together in Italy to visiting each others first homes/ attending weddings /welcoming in motherhood and most recently keeping up on Marco Polo I am thankful for these gals.     Recreating a picture from 7 yrs ago 😂  As we were saying our goodbyes we looked down and BURST into laughter. Must be a 40 yr old thing.  Memories upon memories with this crew.  xo. edc.   

Dan and Pam +

 One of our favorite weeks of summer came and went: When Dan and Pam visit. This means lots of family time at Big C. Everything is a game and there are lots of laughs-- never ending fun. It always goes by so fast and it’s sad to see them go.  This year we did something super different and took a 24 hour trip to show off Duluth to Pam. J is the best trip planner and when she sent me the itinerary I knew it was going to be a good time.  Here we are in our little hostel room. I slept like a rock thanks to half a sleeping pill. Seriously. I slept over 9 hours and didn’t even wake up to go to the bathroom!  Found just a couple rocks to skip 😂  Here we are at split rock lighthouse. We were too cheap to go into the actual park and get the tour so we listened to a podcast on the way home instead haha  The fog hadn't burned off yet and it made for the most beautiful backdrop.  Perhaps the highlight for me: burrata and wine on the rocks of gooseberry falls. We ...